|
Filtering / Blocking
|
WebChaver Internet Accountability |
| Provides blocking without accountability. | Provides accountability without blocking. |
| Does not monitor and rate the sites viewed. Blocked sites are determined by an outside standard. | Monitors all website visits, including image searches, newsgroups, most file-sharing and FTP. Helps build self- control, self-discipline, integrity, and personal accountability. Monitors without blocking. |
| Blocks most objectionable websites from appearing on your computer screen. The best filters have white lists (the Account Guardian chooses a list of allowed sites, and all other sites are blocked). They also allow optional control for time of day or total time spent by a user on the Internet. The best ones also allow blocking of specific protocols such as file-sharing, newsgroups, FTP, etc. | Does not block any sites from being viewed, but teaches responsible use of the Internet. Knowing that your Accountability Partner will be "looking over your shoulder" eliminates temptation. |
| May block acceptable websites, causing frustration. | Does not block all objectionable websites, possibly exposing individuals to harmful, objectionable material. |
| Filters may slow the speed of Internet access down. | CE is designed not to slow Internet access down. |
| Most filters can be bypassed allowing the user access to objectionable websites without anyone knowing it. | The program is extremely difficult to bypass (even for techies). |
| Filters do not need Accountability Partners. | Accountability Partners need to view the reports in a timely manner and communicate when needed. |
| Filters do not build self-control, self-discipline, nor do they hold anyone accountable for their Internet use. They do not involve an accountability person. | The scoring of websites is an indicator of possible pornographic content. Information is provided in a report which is easy to understand. Internet accountability brings in Accountability Partner(s) to help you be accountable and keep you safe on the Internet. |
| No one knows if a person has uninstalled the filter to possibly view objectionable material. | Covenant Eyes© is designed to notify a partner via email if the user tries to tamper with the program, uninstall it, or remove their Accountability Partner(s). |
| The best filters allow individual settings for different users. Only the administrator for a filter account has access to the password to make changes. | Able to have separately scored Accountability Reports for each person in the family, staff, or company. Administrators have access to Administrative Summary Reports which allows a quick view of large accounts. |
| Filtering is most appropriate for young children beginning to learn the Internet, or for any family just starting out with a computer. Filtering is also appropriate for individuals who are worried about accidentally encountering an objectionable site. | Accountability should be used by anybody who uses the Internet even if filtering is also used. |